Archives     Advertise     Editorial Calendar     Subscribe     Contact Us    


DOJ Signals New Approach to Frivolous Qui Tam Actions


 

The Department of Justice (DOJ) recently made a surprising announcement that it may begin seeking dismissal of meritless qui tam cases brought under the False Claims Act. This announcement was made by Michael Granston, director of the Civil Fraud Section of the DOJ's Civil Division, at the Health Care Compliance Association's Healthcare Enforcement Compliance Institute in November 2017.[i]

The False Claims Act permits an individual, known as a "qui tam relator" (or more commonly, a "whistleblower"), to bring a lawsuit on behalf of the United States when that person has information that the defendant "knowingly" submitted false or fraudulent claims to the federal government.[ii] Liability for violations of the False Claims Act includes civil penalties and treble damages.

More than half of the False Claims Act recovery comes from the healthcare industry, the vast majority of which results from qui tam actions. In 2016 alone, the federal government obtained more than $4.7 billion in settlements and judgments under the False Claims Act, with $2.5 billion of this coming from the healthcare industry.[iii] And almost nine out of 10 False Claims Act cases within the healthcare industry have traditionally resulted from qui tam claims.[iv]

The False Claims Act includes detailed procedures and requirements for filing a qui tam action. Among other things, the complaint must be filed under seal for at least 60 days while the DOJ investigates. After its investigation, the DOJ may (1) intervene and prosecute one or more of the claims as a plaintiff; (2) decline to intervene, in which case the relator may prosecute the claims on behalf of the United States; or (3) move to dismiss the complaint.

Regarding the third option, the DOJ has statutory authority to move to dismiss a False Claims Act case that lacks merit even over the relator's objection, as long as the government gives sufficient notice of the motion and the relator has an opportunity to request a hearing.

Although courts have generally been extremely deferential to the DOJ's decision to dismiss a qui tam action, the DOJ has rarely exercised this authority. Instead, the second option is far and away the most frequently used by the DOJ: it intervenes in fewer than 25 percent of qui tam actions, and in virtually all of the other instances, it traditionally allows the relator to proceed with the case regardless of its merits.[v]

Nevertheless, a very small portion of the total False Claims Act recovery over the past several decades -- less than five percent -- has resulted from cases in which the DOJ declined to intervene.[vi] Accordingly, the government's decisions in around 75 percent of qui tam cases -- to neither intervene nor seek dismissal - has forced defendants to incur substantial litigation costs defending against a significant number of meritless claims. The government's stated intention to begin seeking dismissal of frivolous qui tam cases recognizes the burden of protracted litigation upon courts and the healthcare industry.

Whether the recent DOJ announcement leads to actual change remains to be seen, but it signifies a potentially encouraging policy shift for healthcare companies that spend millions of dollars every year defending frivolous qui tam actions.

In fact, on January 10, Director Granston issued a memorandum providing specific guidance as to how the DOJ will approach evaluating whether to seek dismissals, which we plan to summarize in next month's edition.

[i] Glaser, David M., Developing Story: DOJ Will Dismiss Qui Tam Cases Lacking Merit. RAC Monitor (Nov. 2, 2017), available at https://www.racmonitor.com/developing-story-doj-will-dismiss-qui-tam-cases-lacking-merit.

[ii] 31 U.S.C. § 3729 et seq.

[iii] See Press Release, Office of Pub. Affairs, U.S. Dep't of Justice, Justice Department Recovers Over $4.7 Billion from False Claims Act Cases in Fiscal Year 2016 (Dec. 14, 2016), https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/‌justice-department-recovers-over-47-billion-false-claims-act-cases-fiscal-year-2016 .

[iv] Fraud Statistics Overview (Dec. 13, 2016), https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/‌918361/download.

[v] See False Claims Act Cases: Government Intervention in Qui Tam (Whistleblower) Suits. United States Department of Justice, available at https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/usao-edpa/legacy/2012/06/13/InternetWhistleblower%20update.pdf

[vi] Id.


J. Matthew Kroplin is a partner in Burr & Forman's Nashville office, practicing in the firm's healthcare and business litigation sections. Adam W. Overstreet is counsel in Burr & Forman's Birmingham office, practicing in the firm's healthcare section, and is a former Assistant United States Attorney.






 
Share:

Related Articles:


Recent Articles

COVID-19 - Where We Stand

As the city moves deeper into reopening, leaders address the need for ongoing precautions and realities of vaccine development.

Read More

AMA Issues New Privacy Principles

From a fitness tracker to healthy eating app, data is everywhere ... but it isn't all protected by HIPAA. The AMA has created a set of privacy principles that put patients in charge of their information.

Read More

Paycheck Protection Program Flexibility Act

Deadlines and information on PPP and provider relief fund.

Read More

"What's Up Doc?" Dealing with a Delayed Patient Volume Bounce

Read More

Financing the Deal

The Nashville Health Care Council's annual "Financing the Deal" panel discussion is always highly anticipated. This year's virtual event was as popular as ever with a focus on deal-making trends and strategies.

Read More

Lending a Hand

Mentorship, wisdom offered to start-ups through Nashville Entrepreneur Center.

Read More

Health Care Council Explores the Road to Economic Recovery

Read More

Nashville-Based Startups Launch New Charity Initiatives

Charity-tech brands GeekCause, Generous, Givful and Kindful have jointly announced a range of new initiatives to support the important work of nonprofits during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Read More

Patient Create Powered by Bridge Connector Now Available in the Epic App Orchard

Read More

Wellview Unveils Daily Symptom Monitoring Platform, WellCheck™

Read More

Email Print
 
 

 

 


Tags:
Adam Overstreet, Burr & Forman, False Claims Act, Matthew Kroplin, Qui Tam, Whistleblower
Powered by Bondware
News Publishing Software

The browser you are using is outdated!

You may not be getting all you can out of your browsing experience
and may be open to security risks!

Consider upgrading to the latest version of your browser or choose on below: