Archives     Advertise     Editorial Calendar     Subscribe     Contact Us    


PRRB Announces Significant Changes to Medicare Appeal Rules


 

On Aug. 29, 2018, the Provider Reimbursement Review Board (PRRB) issued new rules containing both technical changes and substantial revisions to its appeal procedures. The 90-page PRRB Version 2.0 applies to both new and pending appeals as of the date of its release, and failure to follow the new requirements could result in a provider's loss of appeal rights. Among the key changes in the new rules are front-loading the grounds for appeal and an emphasis on electronic filing.

The PRRB is an independent panel created by Congress in 1972 and has jurisdiction over certain Medicare appeals by Part A providers. PRRB appeals stem from provider disagreement with reimbursement determinations by the Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) after its review of the provider's annual cost report, assuming the requisite amount is in dispute. The PRRB's goal is to "facilitate early resolution of appeals and eliminate unnecessary filing burdens where appropriate." The PRRB's decision may be affirmed, modified, reversed, or vacated by the CMS Administrator.

The new rules now require a full preliminary position paper, including exhibits, to be filed with the PRRB at the beginning of the appeal. By now having these materials provided to the PRRB from the outset, instead of just to the MAC, it effectively requires the appealing provider to set forth its formal position from day one. Commentary to the rules now explain that "preliminary position papers are expected to present fully developed positions of the parties and, therefore, require analysis well in advance of the filing deadline." Reinforcing this expectation, the new rules explain that "[n]ew arguments and documents not included in the preliminary position paper may be excluded at hearing unless the parties demonstrate good cause."

In addition, the new rules eliminate the requirements for a final position paper in any appeal filed after Aug. 29, 2018 and for a post-hearing brief in all appeals. Going forward, both will be optional with the former potentially being used to narrow the issues prior to hearing and the latter being subject to the PRRB's request.

Another significant change is the new reinstatement option, which allows providers to preserve their appeal rights while attempting to resolve their Medicare payment decisions at issue with the MAC. If unsuccessful, the provider can reinstate the appeal to pursue it before the PRRB.

In conjunction with the new rules, and to advance its stated goal of reducing unnecessary filing burden on providers, the PRRB is also shifting to an electronic filing system through the creation of the Office of Hearings Case and Document Management System (OH CDMS). The new rules state that, although "not currently required, the PRRB strongly recommends all parties utilize this new electronic case management tool." As guidance, CMS recently released an external user manual for OH CDMS, and providers (or their representatives) may register for the OH CDMS online. During the transition period, the PRRB will continue to accept hard copy submissions by mail, but it will not accept submissions by email or fax.

In addition to an emphasis on early position development, the new rules provide additional clarity, a new reinstatement option, and access to electronic filing. But they also create potential landmines for filing providers, who must be careful to satisfy the requirements of the updated rules to avoid risking significant money at issue on appeal.


Matthew Kroplin is a partner in the Nashville office of Burr & Forman, LLP. Kroplin, whose work is focused in the firm's healthcare and business litigation sections, is certified in healthcare compliance (CHC). He provides counsel to a broad range of health care industry clients, including providers, medical groups, hospitals, and surgery centers. For more information, go online to burr.com.




WEB:

Burr & Forman, LLP

Revised PRRB Rules

 
Share:

Related Articles:


Recent Articles

VUMC Joins International Effort to Speed Vaccine Development

Vanderbilt University Medical Center (VUMC) has joined an international effort to streamline and accelerate development of vaccines and other treatments against a growing worldwide surge of deadly and debilitating viral infections.

Read More

U.S. Senator Lamar Alexander on legislation he introduced this week to lower the cost of health care

There's one question I hear almost every day from Tennesseans, and it is, "What are you doing to lower the cost I pay for health care?"

Read More

So excited to spend the morning celebrating the Women to Watch Class of 2019

Read More

Alexander: Bipartisan Legislation Will Lower What Americans Pay Out of Their Own Pockets for Health Care

The Lower Health Care Costs Act of 2019 contains nearly three dozen proposals from at least 16 Republican, 14 Democrat senators

Read More

If You Build It, They Will Come

Middle Tennessee's healthcare options continue to expand through new construction and facility renovations and additions.

Read More

Lease, Build, Buy, Sell: Finding the Best Fit for Each Medical Practice

When it comes to medical real estate, there is no one 'right' answer for every practice. Instead, experts say it's important to understand all the options before making a decision that impacts individual physicians, the practice ... and ultimately, patients.

Read More

Dr. Jerry Tannenbaum: Redefining, Redesigning Nephrology

Innovative building models and telemedicine mean better care for patients nationwide.

Read More

Wayfinding in Healthcare

With expansions, renovations and additions to healthcare facilities over time, the ability to easily navigate a campus is often lost along the way. Taking time to consider wayfinding can vastly improve the way patients, visitors and staff engage with the environment.

Read More

Building Walls

Steve Ward & Associates prefab headwalls mean more savings, options for healthcare clients.

Read More

LipiFlow®: Advanced Procedure to Treat Meibomian Gland Dysfunction & Chronic Dry Eye

In-office procedure can promote eyelid health and provide relief from dry eye.

Read More

Email Print
 
 

 

 


Tags:
Burr Forman, MAC, Matt Kroplin, Matthew Kroplin, Medicare Administrative Contractor, Medicare Appeal, Medicare Part A, Provider Reimbursement Review Board, PRRB
Powered by Bondware
News Publishing Software

The browser you are using is outdated!

You may not be getting all you can out of your browsing experience
and may be open to security risks!

Consider upgrading to the latest version of your browser or choose on below: