Archives     Advertise     Editorial Calendar     Subscribe     Contact Us    



Accounting for Social Risk Factors in Value-Based Payment


 

Healthcare providers are becoming more responsible for ensuring the efficiency and quality of the care they provide to Medicare beneficiaries. The shift toward value-based payment models means that measurements of efficiency and quality of care are increasingly used to determine financial bonuses and penalties.

A recent report by a committee of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM, formerly the Institute of Medicine) --on which one of us served --finds benefits of adjustment of such measures for both clinical and social risk factors. Clinical risk factors are physiological attributes that can be associated with increased risk of certain diseases and health outcomes: they are already used to adjust quality and efficiency measures. Social risk factors are patient attributes such as low socioeconomic position, minority race or ethnic background, minority sexual orientation or gender identity, or living in a deprived setting.

Research has shown that these social risk factors influence health-related outcomes: patients with these attributes have worse health outcomes, and providers that disproportionately serve them appear to, as well. If they are not measured and adjusted for as clinical risk factors are, providers who serve disadvantaged populations could be unfairly penalized.1 In addition, providers might work to reduce the effects of social risk factors but doing so could require additional staff effort and costs. If social risk factors beyond providers' control are not accounted for, and providers serving disproportionate numbers of patients with high degrees of social risk are penalized, then disparities in health outcomes could widen.

Thus, in order to achieve the goal of accounting for social risk factors in Medicare payment programs and compensating providers fairly, the NASEM committee was commissioned to "specify criteria that could be used in determining which socioeconomic status factors should be accounted for in Medicare quality measurement and payment systems."1 The committee found that these goals could be reached with a combination of approaches. Specifically, depending on the measure and context, a combination of approaches might be used to account for social risk factors without masking real differences in performance. The approaches are:

  • Stratified public reporting by social risk factors within reporting units to illuminate how providers serve those with risk factors.
  • Adjusted performance measures to standardize estimates of quality.
  • Direct adjustment of payments to providers who disproportionately serve those with social risk factors.
  • Restructured payment incentives to reward improved quality or high-value care.

The committee also found that development of new data sources and methods of measurement would be beneficial in identifying indicators of social risk. Table 1 shows the five major categories of measures considered important by the committee, and specific examples of measures in each category, which may be ready for use. One example is that data are ready for use on dual eligibility for Medicare and Medicaid (an indicator of low income), and the Medicare program could use them to adjust measures of - and penalties for - hospital readmissions.


In addition, work to improve the accuracy of social risk data and use it for payment and quality measurement would likely benefit providers and patients in Nashville.1,2 Davidson County's poverty rate is higher than the U.S. average, and Nashville has a higher proportion of citizens who are members of minority races and ethnicities. 3 Accounting for social risk factors that a significant numbers of Nashvillians face would not only benefit the providers who serve these disadvantaged populations, but those directly affected by social risk factors themselves.

1 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, Accounting for social risk factors in Medicare payment. Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2017.

2 Buntin, MB, Ayanian, JZ. Social Risk Factors and Equity in Medicare Payment. NEJM. 2017 Feb 9; 376:607-510.

3 People Living Below Poverty Level by Race/Ethnicity, Nashville TN. HealthNashville.org (2015). Retrieved: March 9, 2017, from www.healthynashville.org Data Source: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey. 2011-2015.


Melinda Buntin, PhD is a Professor of health economics and the Chair of the Department of Health Policy at Vanderbilt University's School of Medicine. More about her Department can be found at https://medschool.vanderbilt.edu/health-policy/ or by following @VUHealthPol.





Aiden Lee is a senior at Vanderbilt University studying Medicine, Health, and Society with a concentration in Health Policies and Economies.








 
Share:

Related Articles:


Recent Articles

Alexander Leads Bipartisan Support for Accelerated FDA Reviews

By a vote of 94-1, the U.S. Senate has sent President Trump a bill addressing FDA user fee agreements meant to speed up the Food & Drug Administration's review of new drugs and devices.

Read More

BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee Partners with TN HIMSS and Belmont University to bring HIT Workforce Education to Chattanooga Region

The Tennessee HIMSS Chapter and the Center for Executive Education at Belmont University will partner with BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee to bring a 14-week certification program to healthcare information technology (HIT) professionals in the Chattanooga region.

Read More

Alzheimer's Foundation Of America Seeking Nominations For Dementia Care Professional Of The Year

The Alzheimer's Foundation of America (AFA) is now accepting nominations for its 2017 "Dementia Care Professional of the Year."

Read More

Addressing Adolescent Angst in a Digital World

Growing up can be difficult in a digital age. Dr. Jess Shatkin shares insights on how primary care providers can support parents in an age of increasing adolescent anxiety and depression.

Read More

Leading the Way

Child neurologist Jeffrey Neul, MD, has been appointed director of the Kennedy Center at VUMC.

Read More

TJC Sharpens Focus on Healthcare Access for Children

Always a champion for children's health, the Tennessee Justice Center is taking more steps to ensure coverage for nearly a million Tennessee kids.

Read More

You Be the 1

You Be the 1 campaign, started by local couple John & May Bumpus, hopes to reach struggling teens through kindness and empathy and connect them to area resources.

Read More

Pediatric Rounds

The Children's Hospital at TriStar Centennial officially celebrated the opening of its new pediatric emergency room last month.

Read More

NMGMA: Ten Minute Takeaway

Phishing, Vishing, SMiShing ... there are an array of sophisticated methods that cyberthieves can use to access PHI.

Read More

Cash in Hand

With increased patient responsibility, collecting for healthcare services can be difficult ... but there are some best practices providers can put in play to maximize timely payments.

Read More

Email Print
 
 

 

 


Tags:
Aiden Lee, Melinda Buntin, Quality Care, Risk Adjustment, Social Determinants of Health, Social Risk Factors, Value-Based Reimbursement, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, VUMC
Powered by Bondware
News Publishing Software

The browser you are using is outdated!

You may not be getting all you can out of your browsing experience
and may be open to security risks!

Consider upgrading to the latest version of your browser or choose on below: